Review of BattleMog – A Case Study – DART #4

BattleMog, previously known as DOTMog, represents a significant development in the blockchain gaming sector, utilizing the innovative Ajuna Network and the Polkadot Unity SDK. This Unity3D game introduces players to Mogwais, a diverse clan of characters that players can train and equip for battles. This review assesses the project’s various facets, including the team, code quality, social media presence, business model, and overall risk.

Read the full DART document for BattleMog.

BattleMog Project Information

• Category: Blockchain Game
• Website: BattleMog
• Platform: Ajuna Network, Polkadot

BattleMog stands out as the first game to leverage the Polkadot Unity SDK, aiming to pioneer this niche in the blockchain gaming space. The game’s unique appeal lies in its characters, Mogwais, which exhibit a range of behaviors from compassionate to fierce, offering a rich gameplay experience.

BattleMog Team

BattleMog’s development is spearheaded by a team of seasoned professionals:

• Cedric Decoster: CEO and CTO, with over 20 years in software engineering and game development.
• Rene Windegger: Senior Software Architect, with extensive experience in full-stack development and blockchain technology.
• Andre Schneider: Former COO, now involved in other capacities.
• Patrik Bundeli: Head of Art and Design.
• Tim Kramarz: Specialist in 3D modeling and animation.

This experienced team brings a blend of technical prowess and creative expertise essential for the project’s success. However, the team’s small size may pose challenges in scaling development to compete with AAA game titles.

BattleMog Code Quality

The project’s code quality demonstrates solid adherence to industry standards, particularly in the BattleMog pallet available on GitHub. Key highlights include:

• Regular commits and active contributions.
• Comprehensive inline comments and integrated code testing.
• Compliance with Rust coding conventions and security measures.

Despite these strengths, the presence of unsafe blocks in the code could pose potential security risks, necessitating thorough reviews to ensure overall safety.

BattleMog Social Media and Community

BattleMog has established a strong community presence across several platforms:

• Discord: 7.89k members
• Telegram: 89 members
• X (formerly Twitter): 4.5k followers
• YouTube: 462 subscribers

The community is highly engaged, with the team maintaining excellent responsiveness and organizing events to boost interaction. This engagement is crucial for the project’s growth and adoption.

BattleMog Business Model

BattleMog aims to revolutionize traditional gaming by integrating blockchain technology, offering verifiable ownership of in-game assets through NFTs and an open marketplace. Key considerations include:

• The innovative use of blockchain technology for asset ownership.
• Potential challenges in mainstream adoption due to the complexities of NFTs and cryptocurrencies.
• Financial risks associated with the volatility of the MOG token used for in-game transactions.

While the concept is promising, the project’s success will depend on its ability to simplify these complexities for a broader gaming audience.

Conclusion and Risk Assessment

BattleMog demonstrates significant potential with its robust business model, experienced team, and active community. However, the small team size, technical challenges, and complexities of integrating blockchain with gaming pose moderate risks. The transition from DOTMog to BattleMog and the need for improved communication and documentation are areas for improvement.

Potential investors and users are advised to monitor the project’s developments closely and conduct thorough due diligence. BattleMog falls into the Moderate Risk category, showing promise but requiring careful attention to its ongoing progress and challenges.